R Tauranga 14 October 2026 – R5 – PASSION ‘N’ PRIDE

ID: RIB71727

Respondent(s):
Samuel Bergerson - Trainer

Applicant:
Margaret Carter (Trainer of COMPULSORY)

Chair Adjudicator:
Jo Howard

Persons Present:
Ms K Jillings (Stipendiary Steward), Mr B Jones (Deputy Chief Stipendiary Steward), Mr J Laking (Stipendiary Steward), Mr Craig Grylls and Ms M Carter (Jockey and Trainer of COMPULSORY), Mr Cooper Stumbles and Mr S Bergerson (Jockey and Trainer PASSION 'N' PRIDE), Mr Noel Harris (Apprentice Mentor)

Information Number:
A17743

Decision Type:
Protest

Rule(s):
642(1) - Riding/driving infringement

Plea:
Contested

Protest:
COMPULSORY 2nd v PASSION 'N' PRIDE 1st

Animal Name:
PASSION 'N' PRIDE

Code:
Thoroughbred

Race Date:
14/10/2026

Race Club:
Racing Tauranga Inc

Race Location:
Tauranga Racecourse - 1383 Cameron Road, Greerton, Tauranga,

Race Number:
R5

Hearing Date:
14/10/2026

Hearing Location:
Racing Tauranga, 1383 Cameron Road, Greerton, Tauranga

Outcome: Protest Dismissed

Penalty: N/A

EVIDENCE – PROTEST

Following the running of Race 5, an Information was filed instigating a Protest pursuant to Rule 642(1). The Applicant, Trainer Ms M Carter and Class A Rider Mr Craig Grylls alleged that horse No.11 PASSION ‘N’ PRIDE (C Stumbles) placed 1st by the Judge, interfered with the chances of horse No. 2 COMPULSORY (C Grylls) placed 2nd by the Judge.

The alleged interference was said to have occurred in the final 100 metres of the race.

The Judge’s provisional placings were as follows:

1st   No. 11   PASSION ‘N’ PRIDE
2nd  No. 2    COMPULSORY
3rd   No. 1     ARTFUL DODGER
4th   No. 6     UNSWAYED
5th   No. 15   IN TUNE

The official margin between 1st and 2nd was a short head.

Rule 642(1) provides:

“If a placed horse or its rider causes interference within the meaning of this rule 642 to another placed horse, and the Adjudicative Committee is of the opinion that the horse so interfered with would have finished ahead of the first mentioned horse had such interference not occurred, they may place the first mentioned horse immediately after the horse interfered with”.

Interference is defined as:

• a horse crossing another horse without being at least its own length and one other clear length in front of such other horse at the time of crossing.
• a horse jostling with another horse, unless it is proved that such jostling was caused by the fault of some other horse or Rider or that the horse or Rider jostled with was partly at fault; or
• a horse itself, or its Rider, in any way interfering with another horse or the Rider of another horse in a Race, unless it is proved that such interference was caused by the fault of some other horse or Rider or that the horse or Rider interfered with was partly at fault.

SUBMISSIONS FOR DECISION

Prior to hearing submissions from the respective parties, the Adjudicative Committee explained the key elements of the Protest process and confirmed that both parties understood the pertinent Interference Rule. For a protest to be successful, two components had to be proved:

1. That interference had occurred.
2. That without it, the affected horse would have beaten the horse which caused the interference.

The race films were shown and the two horses involved identified. Front, side and back straight views of the race were all used extensively in evidence.

INFORMANT’S EVIDENCE

Mr Grylls explained that approaching the 200m mark, COMPULSORY had a head margin on his mount PASSION ‘N’ PRIDE, and they were very close to one another at this point. Mr Stumbles (COMPULSORY) changed his whip from his left hand to his right, which contributed to his mount shifting outwards. This dictated his own mount outwards, involving a small bump. This closeness prevented Mr Grylls from using his whip, which was in his right hand and this caused the margin to be taken off him.

Ms Carter added that COMPULSORY was clearly leading at the 200m mark and the whip hand change by Mr Stumbles, contributed to COMPULSORY finishing in 2nd place.

RESPONDENT’S EVIDENCE

Mr Bergerson (Co-Trainer PASSION ‘N’ PRIDE) admitted that there was no denying that both horses shifted out in the last 100 metres. Mr Grylls was a neck in front and had every chance to carry on and go past PASSION ‘N’ PRIDE. He acknowledged that there was a minor brush, but COMPULSORY’S history is that of a non-winner. He emphasised that Mr Grylls didn’t stop riding to the fullest and wasn’t hindered in that regard.

Mr Stumbles added that he changed his whip to give his mount added encouragement in the final 100 metres, as he was too close to Mr Grylls’ mount to use the whip in his left hand.

STEWARD’S INTERPRETATION

Stipendiary Steward Ms K Jillings outlined the Stewards’ interpretation of the alleged interference. She said that while Mr Stumbles (COMPULSORY) had moved out, dictating Mr Grylls (PASSION ‘N’ PRIDE) wider, the brush between the two horses inside the 100 metres was only slight. The Adjudicative Committee had to determine whether the interference was sufficient that if it had not occurred, COMPULSORY would have beaten PASSION ‘N’ PRIDE.

REASONS FOR DECISION

Following the requirements of the Protest Rule, the Adjudicative Committee must firstly be satisfied that interference occurred; and secondly, if interference was proven, the horse interfered with would have beaten the other runner, had such interference not occurred.

The standard of proof is on the balance of probabilities, which simply means ‘more probable than not’ that the horse interfered with would have beaten that runner.

After considering all the evidence, the Adjudicative Committee found that over the concluding stage of the race (final 100 metres), there was movement out by PASSION ‘N’ PRIDE and that horse and COMPULSORY momentarily brushed, but only very slightly. At the 200m, COMPULSORY did hold the lead from PASSION ‘N’ PRIDE by a small margin. However, PASSION ‘N’ PRIDE finished the race off the stronger, kicking back and beating COMPULSORY by a short head.  The slight interference did not appear to cause COMPULSORY to become unbalanced and Mr Grylls was still able to continue riding out the race vigourously.

Therefore, after considering the various contributing factors, and in particular the nature of the interference; manner in which both horses finished the race off over the final stages and the short head margin, the Adjudicative Committee could not be comfortably satisfied that had the interference not occurred, COMPULSORY would have finished in advance of PASSION ‘N’ PRIDE.

Accordingly in the exercise of the Adjudicative Committee’s discretion, the protest is dismissed.

DECISION

The protest is dismissed, and the Adjudicative Committee authorised the payment of dividends and stake money as per its decision.

Decision Date: 14/10/2026

Publish Date: 15/10/2026