NZ Metropolitan TC 13 November 2026 – R2 – Gavin Smith

ID: RIB72980

Respondent(s):
Gavin Dean Smith

Applicant:
Deputy Chief Stipendiary Steward, Scott Wallis

Chair Adjudicator:
Russell McKenzie

Panel Members:
Dave Anderson

Persons Present:
Mr Wallis, Mr Smith and Open Driver, Craig Ferguson

Information Number:
A21532

Decision Type:
Race Related Charge

Charge:
Careless Driving

Rule(s):
869(3)(b) - Riding/driving infringement

Plea:
Not Admitted

Animal Name:
Beaudiene Always B

Code:
Harness

Race Date:
13/11/2025

Race Club:
Ashburton Trotting Club

Race Location:
Ashburton Racecourse - Racecourse Road, Ashburton, 7700

Race Number:
R2

Hearing Date:
13/11/2026

Hearing Location:
Addington Raceway, Christchurch

Outcome: Not Proved

Penalty: N/A

INFORMATION A21532:

Following the running of Race 2, Road Metals Mobile Pace (Listed Race), Licensed Open Driver, Gavin Smith, denied a charge that, as the Driver of BEAUDIENE ALWAYS B in the race, he “drove carelessly shortly after the start when shifting inwards checking STUMBLIN IN (Craig Ferguson) shortly after the start”.

Rule 869 provides as follows:

(3)   No driver in any race shall drive:-

      (b) carelessly

EVIDENCE:

Deputy Chief Stipendiary Steward, Scott Wallis, had Steward, Shane Renault, show the   available video replays of the first 200 metres of the race – a 1980 metres mobile start. Mr Renault pointed out the two runners – BEAUDIENE ALWAYS B, driven by Mr Smith, coming out of barrier position 6 and STUMBLIN IN, barrier 5.

Mr Wallis that Mr Renault would show, on the video replays, Mr Smith progress forward on the outside of Mr Ferguson and shift down the track, forcing Mr Ferguson to restrain his runner which in turn breaks. It was not being alleged that there was any contact but, rather, that the inwards shift by Mr Smith, resulting in Mr Ferguson having to restrain his horse, caused that horse to break.

Mr Wallis submitted that it appeared from the side-on replay that Mr Smith was clearly not clear of Mr Ferguson. From another camera angle, it appeared that he was clear, Mr Wallis said. However, from all other camera angles including the drone, and from the evidence which Mr Ferguson will give, it was the allegation of Stewards that Mr Smith was not sufficiently clear.

Mr Ferguson said that his horse had broken shortly after the start. He said, just after he had taken a hold of the horse when he received a “little tightening” from Mr Smith on his outside. He then went on to say that he felt that, if he had not taken a hold at that time, there was a chance that “things were going to get tight”. Furthermore, he felt that with Mr Smith intending to go forward he had taken evasive action at a stage of the race at which he did not feel would be detrimental to his horse’s chances. He added that his horse would have continued in its correct gait had he not had to restrain it.

Mr Smith asked for the head-on replay to be shown. He asked Mr Ferguson whether, having seen that replay, he actually needed to have taken a hold. Mr Ferguson said that he was just being “cautious”, and would finish up in the same position as he would have. Mr Ferguson acknowledged that the horse can do things wrong. Mr Smith confirmed that there had been no contact, and there had been no yelling.

Finally, Mr Wallis summed up the submissions he had earlier made.

DECISION:

The charge was dismissed.

REASONS FOR DECISION:

The test for careless driving is whether the driver exercised the degree of care and attention that a reasonable and prudent driver would exercise. It is important to note that it is not a standard of perfection.  As normally understood in a harness racing context, a careless act or omission would normally have consequences to another runner – causing interference, striking a wheel, forcing another runner over pylons or similar consequences.

It has been alleged that Mr Smith has driven carelessly in crossing Mr Ferguson when not sufficiently clear. That means, in a harness racing context, that a horse or driver has not established enough separation from another runner to undertake a manoeuvre without interfering with, impeding or disadvantaging that runner. It is a question of fact and degree, assessed in the circumstances of the particular incident.

The Committee had the advantage of viewing video replays from four different cameras. The Committee found that the video replays were largely inconclusive, apart from one such camera which appeared to show adequate and safe clearance.

Mr Ferguson’s evidence was not entirely persuasive, or definitive of what had happened. His actions, in taking precautions to avoid an incident, were subjectively reasonable and no fault can be apportioned to him for his horse breaking.

As for Mr Smith’s actions, the Committee cannot be satisfied, to the sufficient degree of the balance of probabilities, that his actions were the cause of Mr Ferguson’s runner breaking at that stage of the race. He is entitled to the benefit of any doubt that this Committee has.

The Committee considers that the proximity of the horses, without more, is insufficient to establish the charge.

The charge was dismissed.

 

 

 

Decision Date: 13/11/2026

Publish Date: 16/11/2026