NZ Metropolitan TC 10 November 2026 – R5 – Kimberley Butt (Heard at Addington on 13 November 2026)

ID: RIB72977

Respondent(s):
Kimberly Anne Butt

Applicant:
Nigel McIntyre, Chief Stipendiary Steward

Chair Adjudicator:
Russell McKenzie

Panel Members:
Dave Anderson

Information Number:
A21532

Decision Type:
Race Related Charge

Charge:
Failing to drive out to end of race

Rule(s):
868(3)

Plea:
Not Admitted

Animal Name:
Easton Doll

Code:
Harness

Race Date:
10/11/2026

Race Club:
NZ Metropolitan Trotting Club Inc

Race Location:
Addington Raceway - 75 Jack Hinton Drive, Addington, Christchurch, 8024

Race Number:
R6

Hearing Date:
13/11/2026

Hearing Location:
Addington Raceway, Christchurch

Outcome: Proved

Penalty: Open Driver, Kimberley Butt, suspended 3 days

INFORMATION A21529:

Following the running of Race 6, Garrards Horse and Hound Mobile Pace, Open Driver, Kimberley Butt, denied a breach of rule 868(3) in that, as the Driver of EASTON DOLL in the race, she “failed to drive her horse out to the end of the race when having a reasonable chance of finishing 4th”.

The information was filed with the Adjudicative Committee on raceday and adjourned sine die. It was heard at the meeting of NZ Metropolitan TC at Addington Raceway on 13 November 2026.

Ms Butt had signed the information “I DO NOT admit a breach of the rule” and she confirmed this at the hearing.

Rue 868 provides as follows:

(3)     Every driver shall drive his or horse out to the end of the race if he or she has any reasonable chance of running first, second, third, fourth, or fifth.

The result of the race was as follows:

1st      9   Franco Lennon

2nd     6   The Coalman

3rd      1   Admor Ella

4th      7   Cinderella Franco

5th      2   Easton Doll

The margin between 4th and 5th was a nose.

EVIDENCE:

Chief Stipendiary Steward, Nigel McIntyre, showed video replays of the final 200-300 metres of the race. He began by pointing out EASTON DOLL, driven by Ms Butt, in the lead as the field turned for home. He said Stewards were concerned that, in the initial part of the run home, Ms Butt used her whip in a compliant manner and driving her runner out, until about 35 metres from the finish, from which point there was no “action” from Ms Butt. Ms Butt was at that stage holding 4th place, but CINDERELLA FRANCO (Craig Thornley), which had been ¾ length behind her, got up to take 4th placing by a nose. The videos showed no reason for Ms Butt to have stopped driving her horse, Mr McIntyre submitted.

Ms Butt said that she led throughout the race and had “copped” some pressure mid-race. The horse was not responding in the run home and, she submitted, almost every other horse was making ground on her. CINDERELLA FRANCO had come from a long way back and had made up “monumental ground”. She said that she did not argue that the perception was not good.

Ms Butt pointed out on the head-on replay that there was a gap between her runner and the eventual winner, FRANCO LENNON (Tim Williams, for SRIRACHA (Maurice McKendry), and it felt like Mr McKendry was coming “rather fast” into a gap that was closing. Conscious of that, she said, she felt for a “split-second” there was a “safety element”.  Nothing happened in hindsight, she said, but there was potential for an “incident”.

DECISION:

The charge was found proved.

REASONS FOR DECISION:

There are two elements to the rule. Firstly, that Ms Butt has failed to drive out EASTON DOLL to the end of the race and, secondly, there must have been a reasonable chance of finishing 4th.

The Committee is satisfied that Ms Butt has failed to drive EASTON DOLL out to the end of the race. She has clearly lifted her hands and ceased driving her horse 30-40 metres from the finishing line, as alleged.

Ms Butt admitted that her drive did not look good, and she accepted that she had, over the last 30 metres or so, failed to drive her horse out. The Committee rejected her argument that she had been concerned from a safety point of view with Mr McKendry, attempting to take a gap to her outside.

Was there a reasonable chance of EASTON DOLL finishing in 4th placing? The Committee takes “reasonable chance” to mean “a likelihood, a prospect or expectation, more likely than not” (RIB v Tomlinson December 2023). Looking at the facts of this case, the margin between 4th and 5th was a nose. The Committee comfortably finds that EASTON DOLL had a reasonable chance of finishing 4th, given that margin and the distance over which she failed to drive out.

Ms Butt also referred to the fact that the horse, eventually placed 4th finished very quickly. That was so. However, that did not assist her, as that is precisely the raison d’etre for the rule.

The Committee is comfortably satisfied that the actions of Ms Butt, or lack of them, over the final 30 metres did not satisfy, from an objective perspective, the obligations imposed on a Driver under the rule to drive his or her horse out to the end of the race which, on this occasion, the Committee finds, Ms Butt has failed to do.

The charge is found proved.

SUBMISSIONS FOR PENALTY:

Mr McIntyre said that Ms Butt has had 233 drives this season, and does not have a previous charge under the rule on her record.

The Penalty Guide starting point for failing to drive out when a reasonable chance of finishing 4th is a 3-days suspension.

Ms Butt said that she wished any term of suspension to commence after the meeting of NZ Metropolitan TC on 20 November.

REASONS FOR PENALTY:

This is a clear case, in the view of the Committee, of failing to drive out to the finish when having a reasonable chance of finishing, in this case, 4th. Ms Butt has ceased urging her runner some 30 metres prior to the finishing line, when in 4th position, and has lost that placing to the fast-finishing CINDERELLA FRANCO on the line. The RIB Harness Racing Penalty Guide (October 2024) is very specific and, the Committee believes, leaves no room for a consideration of mitigating factors. In the case of a reasonable chance of running 4th, the Penalty Guide provides a penalty of a 3-days suspension.

Accordingly, the penalty is a 3-days suspension.

CONCLUSION:

Ms Butt’s application for a deferment of suspension is granted.

Open Driver, Kimberley Butt, is suspended from after the close of racing on 20 November up to and including 27 November – 3 days

Decision Date: 13/11/2026

Publish Date: 17/11/2026