NZ Metropolitan TC 13 November 2026 – R11 – Tony Herlihy

ID: RIB72989

Respondent(s):
Anthony Grant Herlihy

Applicant:
Deputy Chief Stipendiary Steward, Scott Wallis

Chair Adjudicator:
Russell McKenzie

Panel Members:
Dave Anderson

Persons Present:
Mr Wallis, Mr Herlihy and Junior Driver, Harrison Orange

Information Number:
A21533

Decision Type:
Race Related Charge

Charge:
Breach of Pushout Rule

Rule(s):
869(4) and (6)(b) and (c) - Riding/driving infringement

Plea:
Not Admitted

Animal Name:
Belle Biddy

Code:
Harness

Race Date:
13/11/2026

Race Club:
NZ Metropolitan Trotting Club Inc

Race Location:
Addington Raceway - 75 Jack Hinton Drive, Addington, Christchurch, 8024

Race Number:
R11

Hearing Date:
13/11/2026

Hearing Location:
Addington Raceway, Christchurch

Outcome: Proved

Penalty: Open Driver, Tony Herlihy, suspended 3 days

INFORMATION A21533:

Following the running of Race 11, Dunstan Horsefeeds Sires’ Stakes Final (Group 1), Open Driver, Tony Herlihy, denied a charge that, as the driver of BELLE BIDDY in the race, he “shifted outwards near the 1600 metres forcing PEPINYASTEP (Harrison Orange) wider on the track”.

Rule 869 provides:

(4)   No driver shall during any race do anything which interferes or is likely to interfere with his own horse and/or any other horse or its progress.

(6)   Subject to sub-rule (4) hereof:-

          (b) a horse during any race shall not be forced to race wider on the track;

(c) a horse during a race shall not move ground outwards once the nose of the wider runner coming forward is in line with or past its sulky wheel and until the wider runner going forward is fully past.

 EVIDENCE:

Deputy Chief Stipendiary Steward, Scott Wallis, showed the available video replays of the 1980 metres mobile start race, as the field neared the 1600 metres. He pointed out BELLE BIDDY, driven by Mr Herlihy, which had drawn barrier position 1, racing at that stage in the trail behind the leader, ETERNAL PERFECTION (Cameron Hart), having been crossed early by that runner. PEPINYASTEP, driven by Mr Orange, which had drawn barrier position 3 on the second row, was racing in the one-out, one-back line directly outside Mr Herlihy and following I’M THE BOSS (Blair Orange), which was progressing to the lead.

Mr Wallis showed that, as the runners approached the bend out of the back straight, JORJA (Kimberley Butt) was progressing forward, 3-wide, past Mr Orange. He showed Mr Herlihy then shift his horse outwards from the marker line into the one-one, forcing Mr Orange wider on the track, and took Mr Orange’s position. Mr Orange was forced 3-wide, before settling back onto the back of Mr Herlihy. Mr Herlihy was not entitled to shift his runner wider with Mr Orange being to his direct outside, Mr Wallis said.

Mr Herlihy asked Mr Wallis if he had considered that Mr Orange’s runner had been hanging out after it left the gate. Mr Wallis said that, if that had been the case, he would not have been charged.

Mr Herlihy said that the replays showed that he had come out when there was room. The horse outside him (Mr Orange’s runner) had “run out fractionally” and he had taken advantage of the gap. He would have been “stupid” not to, he said. He did not interfere with Mr Orange’s horse, he said. It had been out for “maybe one stride, two strides” and had then “hung itself out there”.

Mr Herlihy called Mr Orange to give evidence. Mr Orange said that his horse had its head around, running out. He was “getting wider and wider on the bend” and, at the time, thought that the gap was there for Mr Herlihy.

Mr Orange, questioned by Mr Wallis, agreed that he was positioned in the one-one but was gradually moving out onto the back of JORJA, to keep his horse relaxed, he said. He was not 3-wide when Mr Herlihy started to move out, he said.

Summing up, Mr Wallis submitted that regardless of whether Mr Orange’s horse was running out, it was still in the one-out line and Mr Herlihy committed a forward movement outwards, forcing Mr Orange wider on the track – a breach of the pushout rule.

DECISION:

The charge was found proved.

REASONS FOR DECISION:

The Committee had listened to the evidence and submissions of the parties and carefully viewed the various video replays shown to the hearing. The Committee found the drone footage particularly helpful.

The Committee is satisfied that the charge has been established.

The Committee is satisfied that Mr Herlihy had, clearly, moved his runner outwards from the marker line when Mr Orange’s runner was directly to his outside, in the one-out line, forcing that runner to race wider on the track. Those are the requirements for a breach of the pushout rule to be established.

The Committee did not accept Mr Herlihy’s defence that Mr Orange’s runner had been hanging out to the extent that it had left a gap for him. He would have been “stupid” not to take that gap, he had said.

The Committee found Mr Orange appeared to be reluctant to give evidence, and hesitant in responding to questions. We did not discount his evidence, but attached little weight to it.

Having viewed the available video replays, the Committee is satisfied that Mr Herlihy’s movement was made in circumstances which breached rule 869(6)(b) and (c), The Committee is therefore satisfied, on the balance of probabilities, that the alleged breach has been established.

SUBMISSIONS FOR PENALTY:

Mr Wallis said that Mr Herlihy is a busy driver. He has had 174 drives in the current season to date, and has no breaches of the rule on his record.

The Penalty Guide starting point for a mid-level breach of the rule in a Group or Listed race is a fine of $400 fine or a 2-days suspension, Mr Wallis said. He submitted that it was an aggravating factor that Mr Herlihy had shifted out from the trail into a position that he would not normally have been entitled to – the one-one rather than three places back on the markers. Stewards were submitting that, in the circumstances, a 3-days suspension would be an appropriate penalty for this breach. Any fine would have to be “significantly higher” than $400.

Mr Herlihy submitted that the breach was “minimal”. Unfortunately, Mr Herlihy called the Committee’s decision “not right”. It had heard the evidence, but did not listen, he said. He submitted that that status of the race as a Group 1 should be irrelevant. A $400 fine was all the breach was worth, he said.

REASONS FOR PENALTY:

The RIB Harness Racing Penalty Guide (October 2024) suggests a starting point for a breach of the pushout rule, in a Group/Listed race, of a $400 fine or a 2-days suspension.

In this case, the breach could be considered above mid-level-level. It was a Group 1 race. That is the first thing to consider. It is a very relevant consideration, despite Mr Herlihy’s submitting otherwise. It is also relevant to look at the consequences of this pushout. Mr Herlihy enabled himself to take up a one-one position in the race, on the back of the eventual winner, JORJA, where he remained until just prior to the home turn. Mr Orange’s runner PEPINYASTEP, lost that one-one position to Mr Herlihy, and was forced to race one place further back in the running line. Mr Herlihy’s runner, had it remained in position, would have been relegated to three places back on the markers, with Mr range in the coveted one-one. That is a significant aggravating factor in the Committee’s view.

The Committee regards this breach as a blatant and obvious breach of the pushout rule. Mr Herlihy moved outwards in a manner which deprived Mr Orange’s runner of its rightful racing position. The movement and its consequences cannot reasonably be characterised as marginal or inadvertent.

The sole mitigating factor is Mr Herlihy’s clear record under the rule.

The Committee took a sufficiently serious view of the breach that it considered that it could only be adequately addressed by a term of suspension. The aggravating factor referred to warrants an uplift from the 2-days starting point under the Penalty Guide.

Mr Herlihy sought a deferment until after the Premier Meeting at Addington on 20 November.

CONCLUSION:

Mr Herlihy’s application for a deferment is granted.

Open Driver, Tony Herlihy, is suspended from after the close of racing on Friday, 20 November 2026, up to and including 3 December 2026 after which date he may drive – 3 days.

 

 

 

(

 

Decision Date: 13/11/2026

Publish Date: 16/11/2026